Karthik Nemani, Barrett Buhler
This is the first paper to examine all U.S. public equity Environmental, Social,
and Governance (ESG) funds offered by the Forum for Sustainable and Responsible
Investment’s (SIF) institutional member firms from 2005 to 2020. For ease of
communication, this will be called the ESG Composite. With a Net Asset Value
(NAV) over $150 billion, these funds comprise nearly half of the U.S. public
equity ESG investment landscape. The article finds that the ESG Composite
maintains performance with the Standard and Poor’s (S&P) 500 total return index
on an overall returns basis with lower volatility, indicating greater
risk-adjusted returns. Factor analysis reveals that the ESG Composite returns
are primarily driven by underleveraged exposure to market returns as well as
prevalence of mid-to-large cap and high beta stocks. When isolating the largest
fund in the ESG Composite — the Parnassus Core Equity Fund (PRBLX) portfolio —
this study finds significant outperformance over the S&P 500 on an overall
returns basis. Factor analysis reveals greater emphasis on underleverage to the
market and greater preference for large cap, high beta stocks. When compared to
the global mutual fund universe, the ESG Composite outperforms in annualized
returns and Sharpe ratios, whereas the PRBLX portfolio outperforms in annualized
returns, annualized Sharpe ratios, annualized alphas, and annualized information
ratios. Conclusions drawn from this study will (1) supplement the discussion on
ESG usefulness and (2) present actionable investment insights.